Missing Person Ohio Family has Closure

TOLEDO, Ohio — Something different laced his voice. Gone were stories of rock concerts in Florida, adventures while hitchhiking south, of a young man who set out to see life.

It was Aug. 17, 1980, and Esaw Rodriguez Jr., was scared. He was alone. There were relatives in Texas he planned to meet, but he was still miles away in Lafayette, La. With everyone he knew miles away, he called collect to his family in Toledo. This wasn’t fun anymore. He called his sister Marta and started to cry.

“I want to come home,” he told her.

http://liarcatchers.com/missing_persons_investigations.html

Marta asked where Esaw was, but he didn’t know any landmarks or at what exit he was dropped off.

Marta said she couldn’t help him, that she couldn’t come get him if he couldn’t tell her where to go. But she wanted him home. She told him to find a Catholic church and ask for help.

Marta Rodriguez went to her mother’s place. Her mother, Pauline Rodriguez, said Esaw called her twice. The first time he said he was sad, he was tired, like when he talked to Marta — but he said he was OK.

Pauline told her son to wash his face, to relax, and call her back. The second call was different.

There was fear. He was all alone in strange place. And something happened. Two men got out of a green pickup truck and were walking toward him, he told his mother, and he was worried. He told his mother he loved her over and over again.

“That was supposed to last me a lifetime,” Pauline said. “I didn’t know it then.”

That’s the last they heard from Esaw.

Esaw Rodriguez Jr.’s family called him “Chick” because he was the youngest, because he was small. It was a term of affection.

Ever trusting, Esaw thought everyone was going to be his friend, despite his mother’s warnings. Many were, and that trust was probably why hitchhiking had such an allure.

In the pictures they have of Esaw, he either smiles wide in a moment of joy or stares straight at the camera, stern, determined.

Esaw never told his family about plans for his life, about careers or dreams. Gonzalez doesn’t think a woman alone can raise a man and said her son was still in many ways a boy. She thinks he was looking for a way to prove the man he was.

At 22, with two friends, he hitchhiked to Clearwater, Fla. There was family there. What he didn’t tell his mother or sisters or friends, though, was that his trip would have a second leg. His two friends headed back to Toledo, but Esaw went west, alone, toward Texas.

His sisters and mother remember now that they’d been to Texas just a month before, for a friend’s funeral, and their brother had occasionally talked about going back.

Esaw called his mother, collect, every single day.

So when the calls stopped coming, Gonzalez knew something was wrong. She first tried to file a missing-person report for her son in Toledo, but police told her she’d have to file the report where he’d last been seen. Her boss gave her two weeks off, and she traveled to Lafayette with two friends to the truck stop from which Esaw disappeared.

They waited and prayed and held out hope Esaw had maybe started a new life in some strange land, eventually to return.

A few days before he left, Esaw told Zavala he was planning to go to Florida and asked if he wanted to come along. Zavala was just out of the military, working two jobs, going to college. He was starting a life, and eventually would become a police officer. So he told his cousin he wouldn’t go with him.

“In a lot of ways, I felt guilty,” he said recently. “I’m responsible in some sort of way.”

Zavala let it haunt him in quiet moments alone in his squad car, when he’d call his aunt and listen to her cry about her lost son.

In 2010, he was coming up on retirement, and an urge started. For what he didn’t then know. He woke up one day and started a search that became one both for his cousin and for his own redemption.

“I couldn’t handle seeing my aunt go to her grave not knowing where her son was at,” he said.

He called his aunt. He said, “Tell me about Chick. Tell me everything you know.”

Gonzalez told him everything. When she was finished, he promised that he would find his cousin and bring him home.

Zavala knew his time was limited.

A longtime police officer, he planned to retire in 2012 from the Wyandotte, Mich., department. He’d have to find Esaw before then. Police officers open certain doors for fellow officers that they don’t for others, he said. Once he retired, those doors would close.

He called dozens of contacts nationwide to get him set up with someone in Lafayette. Finally, the calls worked, and he found an investigator in that city’s police department who’d talk to him.

The investigator told him no departments in the area had any missing-person report for Esaw. Nobody had been looking for him.

Zavala persuaded Lafayette police to take a report on his cousin and got a written statement from Gonzalez. Now, Esaw’s information was in the system; Lafayette police put his report into the FBI’s National Crime Information Center, a national database all police can check.

“The first time in all these years my cousin’s information, this missing kid, will be in that computer,” he said. “It should have been many years ago.”

Next, he persuaded forensic experts in Louisiana to accept a DNA sample from the Rodriguez family, free of charge. Then, they put Esaw on the missing-person database.

Zavala searched that system for hours, looking for cases that matched his cousin’s: young white Hispanic males found dead in the early 1980s between Florida and Louisiana. He pored over gruesome cases, of terrible pictures and details, looking for Esaw.

In February, a call came.

An officer from Zavala’s department phoned him at home and said there was a message left for him at the Wyandotte police station from Texas, and it sounded urgent.

He called the number. Dr. Deborrah Pinto, a forensic anthropologist from Harris County, Texas, picked up.

“We’ve got your DNA sample. I’ve got some good news, and some bad news.”

Zavala paused. He asked about the bad news first.

“The bad news is that it’s a homicide,” Pinto told him. “The good news is there’s a 99.9 percent likelihood we’ve identified your cousin.”

His skeleton was found on Jan. 14, 1984, under a bridge just outside downtown Houston. The site was about 20 yards from I-10, the same highway from which Chick had called home from the Louisiana truck stop.

He’d suffered blunt-force trauma to his skull.

And that is almost everything that’s known about what happened to Esaw.

Records don’t show an estimated time of death. Nobody knows if he died under the bridge or was dumped there. Houston police say the case is active, although solving the crime seems nearly impossible. But at least they found him.

His family still waits for his return.

“I know I’m not going to get a body, but it’ll be my son,” Gonzalez said. “We want him to come home.”

Once Esaw’s remains are released, cousins in Texas will drive them to Toledo. They’ll hold a small service for family, then bury his ashes.

Now, they can remember Esaw as Chick, their brother. Not somebody who is lost.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigator Lexington | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Missing Person Ohio Family has Closure

Fraud Investigation Common Fraud Schemes

The following are some of the most common scams that the FBI investigates and tips to help prevent you from being victimized. Visit our White-Collar Crime and Cyber webpages for more fraud schemes.

To report cases of fraud, use our online tips form or contact your nearest FBI office or overseas office.

http://liarcatchers.com/fraud_investigation.html

Telemarketing Fraud

When you send money to people you do not know personally or give personal or financial information to unknown callers, you increase your chances of becoming a victim of telemarketing fraud.

Here are some warning signs of telemarketing fraud—what a caller may tell you:

“You must act ‘now’ or the offer won’t be good.”
“You’ve won a ‘free’ gift, vacation, or prize.” But you have to pay for “postage and handling” or other charges.
“You must send money, give a credit card or bank account number, or have a check picked up by courier.” You may hear this before you have had a chance to consider the offer carefully.
“You don’t need to check out the company with anyone.” The callers say you do not need to speak to anyone including your family, lawyer, accountant, local Better Business Bureau, or consumer protection agency.
“You don’t need any written information about their company or their references.”
“You can’t afford to miss this ‘high-profit, no-risk’ offer.”

If you hear these or similar “lines” from a telephone salesperson, just say “no thank you” and hang up the telephone.

Tips for Avoiding Telemarketing Fraud:

It’s very difficult to get your money back if you’ve been cheated over the telephone. Before you buy anything by telephone, remember:

Don’t buy from an unfamiliar company. Legitimate businesses understand that you want more information about their company and are happy to comply.
Always ask for and wait until you receive written material about any offer or charity. If you get brochures about costly investments, ask someone whose financial advice you trust to review them. But, unfortunately, beware—not everything written down is true.
Always check out unfamiliar companies with your local consumer protection agency, Better Business Bureau, state attorney general, the National Fraud Information Center, or other watchdog groups. Unfortunately, not all bad businesses can be identified through these organizations.
Obtain a salesperson’s name, business identity, telephone number, street address, mailing address, and business license number before you transact business. Some con artists give out false names, telephone numbers, addresses, and business license numbers. Verify the accuracy of these items.
Before you give money to a charity or make an investment, find out what percentage of the money is paid in commissions and what percentage actually goes to the charity or investment.
Before you send money, ask yourself a simple question. “What guarantee do I really have that this solicitor will use my money in the manner we agreed upon?”
Don’t pay in advance for services. Pay services only after they are delivered.
Be wary of companies that want to send a messenger to your home to pick up money, claiming it is part of their service to you. In reality, they are taking your money without leaving any trace of who they are or where they can be reached.
Always take your time making a decision. Legitimate companies won’t pressure you to make a snap decision.
Don’t pay for a “free prize.” If a caller tells you the payment is for taxes, he or she is violating federal law.
Before you receive your next sales pitch, decide what your limits are—the kinds of financial information you will and won’t give out on the telephone.
Be sure to talk over big investments offered by telephone salespeople with a trusted friend, family member, or financial advisor. It’s never rude to wait and think about an offer.
Never respond to an offer you don’t understand thoroughly.
Never send money or give out personal information such as credit card numbers and expiration dates, bank account numbers, dates of birth, or social security numbers to unfamiliar companies or unknown persons.
Be aware that your personal information is often brokered to telemarketers through third parties.
If you have been victimized once, be wary of persons who call offering to help you recover your losses for a fee paid in advance.
If you have information about a fraud, report it to state, local, or federal law enforcement agencies.

For More information:
– Telemarketing Fraud Targeting Seniors

back to top

Nigerian Letter or “419” Fraud

Nigerian letter frauds combine the threat of impersonation fraud with a variation of an advance fee scheme in which a letter mailed from Nigeria offers the recipient the “opportunity” to share in a percentage of millions of dollars that the author—a self-proclaimed government official—is trying to transfer illegally out of Nigeria. The recipient is encouraged to send information to the author, such as blank letterhead stationery, bank name and account numbers, and other identifying information using a fax number provided in the letter. Some of these letters have also been received via e-mail through the Internet. The scheme relies on convincing a willing victim, who has demonstrated a “propensity for larceny” by responding to the invitation, to send money to the author of the letter in Nigeria in several installments of increasing amounts for a variety of reasons.

Payment of taxes, bribes to government officials, and legal fees are often described in great detail with the promise that all expenses will be reimbursed as soon as the funds are spirited out of Nigeria. In actuality, the millions of dollars do not exist, and the victim eventually ends up with nothing but loss. Once the victim stops sending money, the perpetrators have been known to use the personal information and checks that they received to impersonate the victim, draining bank accounts and credit card balances. While such an invitation impresses most law-abiding citizens as a laughable hoax, millions of dollars in losses are caused by these schemes annually. Some victims have been lured to Nigeria, where they have been imprisoned against their will along with losing large sums of money. The Nigerian government is not sympathetic to victims of these schemes, since the victim actually conspires to remove funds from Nigeria in a manner that is contrary to Nigerian law. The schemes themselves violate section 419 of the Nigerian criminal code, hence the label “419 fraud.”

Tips for Avoiding Nigerian Letter or “419” Fraud:

If you receive a letter from Nigeria asking you to send personal or banking information, do not reply in any manner. Send the letter to the U.S. Secret Service, your local FBI office, or the U.S. Postal Inspection Service. You can also register a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission’s Complaint Assistant.
If you know someone who is corresponding in one of these schemes, encourage that person to contact the FBI or the U.S. Secret Service as soon as possible.
Be skeptical of individuals representing themselves as Nigerian or foreign government officials asking for your help in placing large sums of money in overseas bank accounts.
Do not believe the promise of large sums of money for your cooperation.
Guard your account information carefully.

For More information:
– Related Online Rental Ads Scheme
– Related Spanish Lottery Scam

back to top

Identity Theft

Identity theft occurs when someone assumes your identity to perform a fraud or other criminal act. Criminals can get the information they need to assume your identity from a variety of sources, including by stealing your wallet, rifling through your trash, or by compromising your credit or bank information. They may approach you in person, by telephone, or on the Internet and ask you for the information.

The sources of information about you are so numerous that you cannot prevent the theft of your identity. But you can minimize your risk of loss by following a few simple hints.

Tips for Avoiding Identity Theft:

Never throw away ATM receipts, credit statements, credit cards, or bank statements in a usable form.
Never give your credit card number over the telephone unless you make the call.
Reconcile your bank account monthly, and notify your bank of discrepancies immediately.
Keep a list of telephone numbers to call to report the loss or theft of your wallet, credit cards, etc.
Report unauthorized financial transactions to your bank, credit card company, and the police as soon as you detect them.
Review a copy of your credit report at least once each year. Notify the credit bureau in writing of any questionable entries and follow through until they are explained or removed.
If your identity has been assumed, ask the credit bureau to print a statement to that effect in your credit report.
If you know of anyone who receives mail from credit card companies or banks in the names of others, report it to local or federal law enforcement authorities.

Advance Fee Schemes

An advance fee scheme occurs when the victim pays money to someone in anticipation of receiving something of greater value—such as a loan, contract, investment, or gift—and then receives little or nothing in return.

The variety of advance fee schemes is limited only by the imagination of the con artists who offer them. They may involve the sale of products or services, the offering of investments, lottery winnings, “found money,” or many other “opportunities.” Clever con artists will offer to find financing arrangements for their clients who pay a “finder’s fee” in advance. They require their clients to sign contracts in which they agree to pay the fee when they are introduced to the financing source. Victims often learn that they are ineligible for financing only after they have paid the “finder” according to the contract. Such agreements may be legal unless it can be shown that the “finder” never had the intention or the ability to provide financing for the victims.

Tips for Avoiding Advanced Fee Schemes:

If the offer of an “opportunity” appears too good to be true, it probably is. Follow common business practice. For example, legitimate business is rarely conducted in cash on a street corner.

Know who you are dealing with. If you have not heard of a person or company that you intend to do business with, learn more about them. Depending on the amount of money that you plan on spending, you may want to visit the business location, check with the Better Business Bureau, or consult with your bank, an attorney, or the police.
Make sure you fully understand any business agreement that you enter into. If the terms are complex, have them reviewed by a competent attorney.
Be wary of businesses that operate out of post office boxes or mail drops and do not have a street address. Also be suspicious when dealing with persons who do not have a direct telephone line and who are never in when you call, but always return your call later.
Be wary of business deals that require you to sign nondisclosure or non-circumvention agreements that are designed to prevent you from independently verifying the bona fides of the people with whom you intend to do business. Con artists often use non-circumvention agreements to threaten their victims with civil suit if they report their losses to law enforcement.

 

Health Care Fraud or Health Insurance Fraud

Medical Equipment Fraud:

Equipment manufacturers offer “free” products to individuals. Insurers are then charged for products that were not needed and/or may not have been delivered.

“Rolling Lab” Schemes:

Unnecessary and sometimes fake tests are given to individuals at health clubs, retirement homes, or shopping malls and billed to insurance companies or Medicare.

Services Not Performed:

Customers or providers bill insurers for services never rendered by changing bills or submitting fake ones.

Medicare Fraud:

Medicare fraud can take the form of any of the health insurance frauds described above. Senior citizens are frequent targets of Medicare schemes, especially by medical equipment manufacturers who offer seniors free medical products in exchange for their Medicare numbers. Because a physician has to sign a form certifying that equipment or testing is needed before Medicare pays for it, con artists fake signatures or bribe corrupt doctors to sign the forms. Once a signature is in place, the manufacturers bill Medicare for merchandise or service that was not needed or was not ordered.

Tips for Avoiding Health Care Fraud or Health Insurance Fraud:

Never sign blank insurance claim forms.
Never give blanket authorization to a medical provider to bill for services rendered.
Ask your medical providers what they will charge and what you will be expected to pay out-of-pocket.
Carefully review your insurer’s explanation of the benefits statement. Call your insurer and provider if you have questions.
Do not do business with door-to-door or telephone salespeople who tell you that services of medical equipment are free.
Give your insurance/Medicare identification only to those who have provided you with medical services.
Keep accurate records of all health care appointments.
Know if your physician ordered equipment for you.

 

Redemption / Strawman / Bond Fraud

Proponents of this scheme claim that the U.S. government or the Treasury Department control bank accounts—often referred to as “U.S. Treasury Direct Accounts”—for all U.S. citizens that can be accessed by submitting paperwork with state and federal authorities. Individuals promoting this scam frequently cite various discredited legal theories and may refer to the scheme as “Redemption,” “Strawman,” or “Acceptance for Value.” Trainers and websites will often charge large fees for “kits” that teach individuals how to perpetrate this scheme. They will often imply that others have had great success in discharging debt and purchasing merchandise such as cars and homes. Failures to implement the scheme successfully are attributed to individuals not following instructions in a specific order or not filing paperwork at correct times.

This scheme predominately uses fraudulent financial documents that appear to be legitimate. These documents are frequently referred to as “bills of exchange,” “promissory bonds,” “indemnity bonds,” “offset bonds,” “sight drafts,” or “comptrollers warrants.” In addition, other official documents are used outside of their intended purpose, like IRS forms 1099, 1099-OID, and 8300. This scheme frequently intermingles legal and pseudo legal terminology in order to appear lawful. Notaries may be used in an attempt to make the fraud appear legitimate. Often, victims of the scheme are instructed to address their paperwork to the U.S. Secretary of the Treasury.

Tips for Avoiding Redemption/Strawman/Bond Fraud:

Be wary of individuals or groups selling kits that they claim will inform you on to access secret bank accounts.
Be wary of individuals or groups proclaiming that paying federal and/or state income tax is not necessary.
Do not believe that the U.S. Treasury controls bank accounts for all citizens.
Be skeptical of individuals advocating that speeding tickets, summons, bills, tax notifications, or similar documents can be resolved by writing “acceptance for value” on them.
If you know of anyone advocating the use of property liens to coerce acceptance of this scheme, contact your local FBI office.

For more information:
– Sovereign Citizen Movement
– Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration: Fact Sheet on Sovereign Citizen Movement

Investment-Related Scams

Letter of Credit Fraud

Legitimate letters of credit are never sold or offered as investments. They are issued by banks to ensure payment for goods shipped in connection with international trade. Payment on a letter of credit generally requires that the paying bank receive documentation certifying that the goods ordered have been shipped and are en route to their intended destination. Letters of credit frauds are often attempted against banks by providing false documentation to show that goods were shipped when, in fact, no goods or inferior goods were shipped.

Other letter of credit frauds occur when con artists offer a “letter of credit” or “bank guarantee” as an investment wherein the investor is promised huge interest rates on the order of 100 to 300 percent annually. Such investment “opportunities” simply do not exist. (See Prime Bank Notes for additional information.)

Tips for Avoiding Letter of Credit Fraud:

If an “opportunity” appears too good to be true, it probably is.
Do not invest in anything unless you understand the deal. Con artists rely on complex transactions and faulty logic to “explain” fraudulent investment schemes.
Do not invest or attempt to “purchase” a “letter of credit.” Such investments simply do not exist.
Be wary of any investment that offers the promise of extremely high yields.
Independently verify the terms of any investment that you intend to make, including the parties involved and the nature of the investment.

 

Prime Bank Note Fraud

International fraud artists have invented an investment scheme that supposedly offers extremely high yields in a relatively short period of time. In this scheme, they claim to have access to “bank guarantees” that they can buy at a discount and sell at a premium. By reselling the “bank guarantees” several times, they claim to be able to produce exceptional returns on investment. For example, if $10 million worth of “bank guarantees” can be sold at a two percent profit on 10 separate occasions—or “traunches”—the seller would receive a 20 percent profit. Such a scheme is often referred to as a “roll program.”

To make their schemes more enticing, con artists often refer to the “guarantees” as being issued by the world’s “prime banks,” hence the term “prime bank guarantees.” Other official sounding terms are also used, such as “prime bank notes” and “prime bank debentures.” Legal documents associated with such schemes often require the victim to enter into non-disclosure and non-circumvention agreements, offer returns on investment in “a year and a day”, and claim to use forms required by the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC). In fact, the ICC has issued a warning to all potential investors that no such investments exist.

The purpose of these frauds is generally to encourage the victim to send money to a foreign bank, where it is eventually transferred to an off-shore account in the control of the con artist. From there, the victim’s money is used for the perpetrator’s personal expenses or is laundered in an effort to make it disappear.

While foreign banks use instruments called “bank guarantees” in the same manner that U.S. banks use letters of credit to insure payment for goods in international trade, such bank guarantees are never traded or sold on any kind of market.

Tips for Avoiding Prime Bank Note Fraud:

Think before you invest in anything. Be wary of an investment in any scheme, referred to as a “roll program,” that offers unusually high yields by buying and selling anything issued by “prime banks.”
As with any investment, perform due diligence. Independently verify the identity of the people involved, the veracity of the deal, and the existence of the security in which you plan to invest.
Be wary of business deals that require non-disclosure or non-circumvention agreements that are designed to prevent you from independently verifying information about the investment.

“Ponzi’ Schemes

“Ponzi” schemes promise high financial returns or dividends not available through traditional investments. Instead of investing the funds of victims, however, the con artist pays “dividends” to initial investors using the funds of subsequent investors. The scheme generally falls apart when the operator flees with all of the proceeds or when a sufficient number of new investors cannot be found to allow the continued payment of “dividends.”

This type of fraud is named after its creator—Charles Ponzi of Boston, Massachusetts. In the early 1900s, Ponzi launched a scheme that guaranteed investors a 50 percent return on their investment in postal coupons. Although he was able to pay his initial backers, the scheme dissolved when he was unable to pay later investors.

Tips for Avoiding Ponzi Schemes:

Be careful of any investment opportunity that makes exaggerated earnings claims.
Exercise due diligence in selecting investments and the people with whom you invest—in other words, do your homework.
Consult an unbiased third party—like an unconnected broker or licensed financial advisor—before investing.

For more information:
– Bernie Madoff Case
– Stanford Case
– Wholesale Grocery Distribution Ponzi Scheme
– ATM Ponzi Scheme
– Victims Turn Tables with Ponzi Scheme

 

Pyramid Schemes

As in Ponzi schemes, the money collected from newer victims of the fraud is paid to earlier victims to provide a veneer of legitimacy. In pyramid schemes, however, the victims themselves are induced to recruit further victims through the payment of recruitment commissions.

More specifically, pyramid schemes—also referred to as franchise fraud or chain referral schemes—are marketing and investment frauds in which an individual is offered a distributorship or franchise to market a particular product. The real profit is earned, not by the sale of the product, but by the sale of new distributorships. Emphasis on selling franchises rather than the product eventually leads to a point where the supply of potential investors is exhausted and the pyramid collapses. At the heart of each pyramid scheme is typically a representation that new participants can recoup their original investments by inducing two or more prospects to make the same investment. Promoters fail to tell prospective participants that this is mathematically impossible for everyone to do, since some participants drop out, while others recoup their original investments and then drop out.

Tips for Avoiding Pyramid Schemes:

Be wary of “opportunities” to invest your money in franchises or investments that require you to bring in subsequent investors to increase your profit or recoup your initial investment.
Independently verify the legitimacy of any franchise or investment before you invest.

Market Manipulation or “Pump and Dump” Fraud

This scheme—commonly referred to as a “pump and dump”—creates artificial buying pressure for a targeted security, generally a low-trading volume issuer in the over-the-counter securities market largely controlled by the fraud perpetrators. This artificially increased trading volume has the effect of artificially increasing the price of the targeted security (i.e., the “pump”), which is rapidly sold off into the inflated market for the security by the fraud perpetrators (i.e., the “dump”); resulting in illicit gains to the perpetrators and losses to innocent third party investors. Typically, the increased trading volume is generated by inducing unwitting investors to purchase shares of the targeted security through false or deceptive sales practices and/or public information releases.

A modern variation on this scheme involves largely foreign-based computer criminals gaining unauthorized access to the online brokerage accounts of unsuspecting victims in the United States. These victim accounts are then utilized to engage in coordinated online purchases of the targeted security to affect the pump portion of a manipulation, while the fraud perpetrators sell their pre-existing holdings in the targeted security into the inflated market to complete the dump.

Tips for Avoiding Market Manipulation Fraud:

Don’t believe the hype.
Find out where the stock trades.
Independently verify claims.
Research the opportunity.
Beware of high-pressure pitches.
Always be skeptical.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigator Lexington | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Fraud Investigation Common Fraud Schemes

Insurance Fraud 12 Dumbest Scams of the Past Decade

Insurance fraud drains more than $50 billion from insurers each year and costs the average U.S. family between $400 and $700 in the form of increased premiums, according to the FBI.

For the most part, they aren’t exactly criminal masterminds. After trolling through a decade’s worth of headlines, we’ve rounded up what could be the 12 dumbest insurance scams around.

From cops to grandmothers, desperate shop owners and the boy next door, these alleged crooks prove fraudsters come in all shapes and sizes.

http://liarcatchers.com/insurance_fraud.html

Gerald Hardin allegedly chopped off a friend’s hand to cash in on a $670,000 dismemberment claim.
Gerald Hardin allegedly chopped off a friend’s hand to cash in on a $670,000 dismemberment claim.

Lexington County Detention Center
If Judd Apatow ever directed a horror film, chances are it’d sound a lot like this complaint filed by South Carolina’s district attorney against Gerald Hardin.

“…in May 2008, Hardin and another person used a pole saw to intentionally cut off the hand of the third participant in the scheme. A pole saw is a small chain saw that is attached to the end of a pole, and it is used to trim tree branches.

….The three participants then submitted claims against a homeowner’s insurance policy and three accidental death and dismemberment policies and received over $671,000.”

If convicted, Hardin faces a $250,000 fine and up to 20 years in prison.
Four women made up a man, faked his death, and staged a funeral––tombstone and all.
Of all the schemes on our list, this one is by far the most complex––and the creepiest.

Four California women were convicted of wire fraud after they allegedly invented a man (“Jim Davis”), faked his death, and then staged a bogus funeral –– complete with actors paid to pose as mourners –– in order to claim $1.2 million in life insurance benefits.

The FBI caught up with former mortuary worker Jean Crump, 67; Faye Shilling, 61; Barbara Ann Lynn, 64; and Lydia Eileen Pearce, 35, in 2010 after two insurance companies launched an investigation into their claims.

From the FBI’s report: “The con artists were so unnerved by this that they had the coffin supposedly holding the remains of Jim Davis unearthed. They filled the casket with a mannequin and cow parts to ensure the proper weight and then sent it to a crematory. Then, they filed phony paperwork stating that he had been cremated and had his ashes scattered over the Pacific Ocean.”
Samiha Guirguis allegedly filed a $10,000 claim for a $1,000 fur coat that was never stolen
Pennsylvania Attorney’s General
When Samiha Guirguis, 59, claimed a Philadelphia department store lost the beloved mink coat she placed in storage in 2005, she forgot one crucial detail: Her name was monogrammed inside it.

At the time, Guirguis received a receipt from the store showing that the coat was valued at $1,000, according to a complaint filed by the state’s attorney general. She allegedly returned to retrieve the coat four years later and not only claimed that it wasn’t hers but that the original coat was worth $10,000.

From the state’s complaint: “Guirguis made a claim for her fur coat under her homeowner’s policy. The charges state that Guirguis denied having made any prior claims in connection with the coat and reported that she had paid $10,388 for the coat. However, the investigation revealed that in 2001 Guirguis had accused another fur-storage facility of substituting a lesser-value coat for her fur.”

In June, she was charged with two counts of criminal attempt/theft by deception, one count of forgery and one count of insurance fraud.

A security camera captured Ronald Moore allegedly faking an injury on a wrecked bus.

SEPTA
When Ronald Moore saw what he thought was a serious bus accident, he hatched the ultimate get-rich-quick scheme: Pretending to be a passenger, he dashed onto the bus, clutched his back in pain and later filed a claim for injuries, prosecutors claimed.

Unfortunately for him, the whole charade was caught on tape.

“It’s almost comical,” Assistant District Attorney Linda Montag told Philly.com after the incident, which went down in April 2011. “It was a very small tap by a taxicab. There wasn’t even a scratch on the bus.”

Moore was ordered to pay a $1,000 fine and sentenced to 2 years of probation.

Another man the camera caught boarding the bus with Moore escaped charges because he never filed an insurance claim.

Insurance salesman allegedly copped to $4 million scam in a fake suicide note.

Team Financial Services
Even his own knowledge of the industry couldn’t help a Enumclaw, Wash. life insurance salesman get away with an alleged multi-million-dollar insurance scheme.

Federal prosecutors say Aaron Travis Beaird not only pilfered $2 million from his clients’ accounts but convinced a family friend to buy a $2 million life insurance policy, then claimed the man died in order to cash it, the Seattle Post Intelligencer reports.

When police investigated, Beaird allegedly parked his car by a bridge and stuffed a suicide note on the dash with an admission of his crime. He signed it ‘Travis the scam man.’

Beaird was later found very much alive in late June. He’s been charged with two counts of wire fraud and awaits trial.

A New Jersey cop allegedly reported his car stolen, then then kept driving it for three years.

N.J. Office Of The Attorney General

New Jersey police officer Suliman Kamara, 30, would have probably gotten away with his alleged auto insurance scam if only he hadn’t continued to drive the car he reported stolen in 2009.

Kamara collected almost $10,000 from Liberty Mutual at the time, but when a representative from his insurance company happened to see the same car parked outside his home three years later, the jig was up.

An investigation by the state’s attorney general revealed Kamara had kept the car but allegedly switched out his old license plate for a new one. If convicted, he could face 5 years in prison and a $15,000 fine.
An L.A. cop allegedly shot himself in the stomach, causing nine schools to shut down.

Los Angeles Unified School District
When L.A.-area school police officer Jeffrey Stenroos, 31, reported “a man with a ponytail and bomber-style jacket shot him in the chest and fled” while he was on patrol in Jan. 2011, local police sprung into action.

The entire area was combed for 10 hours by 550 police officers and as many as 9 schools were locked down during the same time period, according to the Los Angeles Police Department.

When no shooter turned up and Stenroos couldn’t keep his story straight about how many shots had been fired, the real story unraveled. Prosecutors claimed he shot himself (he was wearing a bullet-proof vest at the time).

Stenroos was convicted of planting false evidence and insurance fraud in Sept. 2011 and a judge ordered him to cough up $309,000 in restitution to the city.

Nicholas Di Puma allegedly set his home and convertible ablaze, then blamed it on bad cooking skills.

A Delaware man claimed a freak cooking accident caused his home and convertible to go up in smoke, but police didn’t buy his Three Stooges-esque story, the Daily Star reported:

“(Nicholas) Di Puma tried to put the fire out with a dishrag, but the dishrag caught fire, so he took one pan and threw it out the front door, where it landed in the backseat of the convertible. He then took the second pan and was going to throw it out, but tripped over a box, and the pan landed on a leather couch, igniting it. Di Puma ran outside to get two hoses, but there was only one there, so he attempted to put out the fire in the convertible, according to the report.”

A state court ordered him to pay $37,997 in restitution and sentenced him to five years of probation for second- and third-degree attempted insurance fraud.

Philly’s 72-year-old ‘Slip-and-Fall Queen’ landed herself on house arrest.

Youtube.com
When Isabel Parker, ran out of funds to support her gambling addiction, the 72-year-old orchestrated no less than 49 slip-and-fall scams at department stores, supermarkets, and liquor stores three states between 1993 and 2000, the Philadelphia Inquirer reported.

An investigation by detectives from the Philadelphia District Attorney’s Insurance Fraud Unit revealed Parker used as many as 47 aliases and 11 different addresses to file her claims, which totaled more than $500,000, according to a joint complaint filed by Philadelphia and Delaware state prosecutors.

She was convicted of 20 counts of insurance fraud in 2003 and served a four-year sentence under house arrest.
Texas wife helps husband dig up a dead body, burn it and file a claim on his life insurance policy.
Texas wife helps husband dig up a dead body, burn it and file a claim on his life insurance policy.

Williams County Sheriff
This is one insurance fraud power couple that proves love really does know no bounds.

According to the Austin Statesman, police claimed Clayton Daniels, 27, dug up the corpse of a deceased 81-year-old woman, dressed her in his own clothes, burned her beyond recognition and stuffed her into his car.

His wife, Molly Daniels, then 25, attempted to collect $110,000 from his life insurance policy, claiming he had been killed in a car accident.

When state police launched an investigation, they found Clayton alive at home––with a new hair dye job. Molly was sentenced to 30 years in prison in 2005 for her role in filing the claim.

Security cameras caught two jewelry wholesalers staging a robbery at their own store.

NBC 4
In December 2008, two New York City business partners hatched the ultimate plan to save their floundering jewelry store––a fake heist.

Prosecutors claimed Atul Shah and Mahaveer Kankariya hired two men, outfitted them in Hasidic jew garb and staged a robbery at their own shop. To cover their tracks, they poured drain cleaner into their security cameras to wreck any footage and then filed $7 million claim with their insurer, Lloyds of London.

The scheme unraveled when police were able to salvage footage from the damaged security tapes that showed the men entering their own safe and removing the jewels just two hours before the supposed burglary.

In March 2011, the pair were convicted of insurance fraud in the first degree, attempted grand larceny and falsifying business records.

Yevgeniy Samsonov allegedly used Wikipedia photos to claim a $20,000 insurance policy on his nonexistent pet cat.

ABC
Washington insurance officials claim a man tried to bilk his insurer out of $20,000 to cover the death of his nonexistent pet cat.

Yevgeniy Samsonov, 29, claimed his furry friend died during a 2009 fender-bender, an accident that already netted him a $3,500 insurance payout for back troubles, according to the Associated Press.

When the insurer, PEMCO, agreed to cut him a $50 check and call it a day, Samsonov allegedly sent photos to prove the cat’s value. A quick web search by the company’s agents proved the pictures were actually gleaned from a Wikipedia page.

Samsonov pled not guilty to insurance fraud charges at a July 11 court hearing. If convicted, he could face a year in jail.

“We’ve handled some pretty unusual fraud cases,” Insurance Commissioner Mike Kreidler said. “But this is one of the stranger ones.”

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigator Lexington | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Insurance Fraud 12 Dumbest Scams of the Past Decade

Arson Investigation Auburn Way Self Storage

AUBURN, Wash. – A four-alarm blaze that swept through an Auburn self-storage facility Wednesday night has been determined to be arson, fire investigators said Friday.

The fire at Auburn Way Self Storage, in the 4500 block of Auburn Way North, broke out at about 6:30 p.m. Wednesday and raged through at least 14 units before it was extinguished hours later. Firefighters needed axes and chainsaws to break through the metal walls of the facility.

http://liarcatchers.com/arson_investigation.html

Investigators believe the fire was deliberately set in a single storage unit in building “E”. The source of ignition and materials first ignited are not being released at this time due to the ongoing investigation, said Valley Regional Fire Authority spokesperson Kimberly McDonald.

Witnesses said the fire spread quickly, sending smoke and flames billowing high into the air.

“It … looked like it was getting bigger and faster, like, really quick and there was no one there,” said one witness, Tom Buchholz, who called 911 when he spotted the flames.

Investigators are currently following up leads in cooperation with the Auburn Police Department.

Anyone who with information they believe would be helpful to the investigation is asked to call the arson tip line at 253-856-4460 and leave a message.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigator Lexington | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Arson Investigation Auburn Way Self Storage

Identity Theft Spanning More Than 30 Years Uncovered

SAN FRANCISCO —

A Michigan man’s discovery that someone was using his identity to obtain medical benefits in California uncovered a decades-long scam, San Francisco police said Friday.

The victim contacted San Francisco police on June 13th after he was denied medical benefits in Michigan and told that someone with his name, date of birth and social security number had health insurance in his name in California, police said. He had never been to California.

http://liarcatchers.com/identity_theft_investigation.html

An investigation led police to the arrest on Thursday of Gregory Harville, 58, a San Francisco resident who allegedly gave the victim’s name when he was arrested and was carrying various identifying documents with the false name.

Investigators determined that Harville had been using the victim’s identity for more than 30 years. He allegedly obtained a drivers license, collected general assistance, held jobs, received traffic citations, been arrested and even served time in state prison under the victim’s name, police said.

Perhaps adding insult to injury, Harville and the victim turned out to have known each other in Michigan more than 30 years ago, police said. Harville was arrested and booked into San Francisco County Jail on felony charges including identity theft, forgery and perjury.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigator Lexington | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Identity Theft Spanning More Than 30 Years Uncovered

Private Detective Drug Addict Doc Duped by Dog X-ray

GLENDORA, Calif. (AP) — Investigators say a Southern California doctor saw enough from an X-ray to prescribe pain killers to an undercover cop but missed the tail showing it was an image of a dog.

Police and Los Angeles County deputies on Thursday raided the Glendora urgent care clinic of 69-year-old Dr. Rolando Lodevico Atiga after a two-month investigation that included three undercover deputies posing as patients.

http://liarcatchers.com/index.php

One of the undercover deputies showed Atiga an X-ray to prove she needed pain killers. The scan of her German shepherd clearly shows the dog’s tail.

The Los Angeles Times reports Atiga examined the X-ray and asked if she wanted Vicodin, oxycodone, Valium or Xanax.

Glendora police Capt. Timothy Staab says Atiga is well known among drug addicts and was considered the doctor to go to.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigator Lexington | Tagged , | Comments Off on Private Detective Drug Addict Doc Duped by Dog X-ray

Identity Theft Diners at Puerta Grande Were Hit with Bank Fraud

Dozens of individuals from Winchester, a small Kentucky town east of Lexington have been targeted by hackers, according to a report earlier this week in the Lexington Herald-Leader. The newspaper claims between 50 and 100 diners at Puerta Grande, a small Mexican restaurant, were hit with bank fraud at some point in the last two weeks.

Local police started receiving calls from banks and individuals regarding the fraudulent charges early last week, but it’s unclear how or when exactly the scam began. Between 12 and 15 banks were hit by the fraud, including one that reportedly lost $30,000.

http://liarcatchers.com/index.php

“It was way too much for an individual person to be at fault here,” according to Winchester Police Detective Dennis Briscoe, who was sourced in the Herald-Leader piece.
Editor’s Pick

In UK Analytics Software Provides Enhanced (Online) Interrogation For Fraud Suspects
Cnet Apologizes for Nmap Adware Bundling
RIM PlayBook Jailbroken, Researchers Claim

Threatpost Newsletter Sign-up

A number of victims discovered their credit and debit cards had been used to make purchases in North Carolina, Florida, Pennsylvania and as far away as Singapore, Australia, Brazil and the Dominican Republic, according to various reports.

The Winchester Sun, the town’s local newspaper claims Puerta Grande has done away with their old credit card scanning system and replaced it with a new system complete with better encryption, following the hack.

According to an another blog post yesterday from Avivah Litan of Gartner, the scam has even affected the local police force. A quarter of Winchester officers “have had unauthorized charges on their credit cards as a result of this incident,” according to the post.

A study last year found that 75 percent of banking fraud was affecting individuals online. Yet while bank fraud has long affected online consumers and bankers alike, attackers thinking small, catering to small businesses and targeting the unsuspected have succeeded greatly.

We learned yesterday that targeted attacks against small businesses have increased this year. In 2012, 36 percent of targeted attacks were aimed at businesses consisting of 250 or less employees, up 18 percent from last year.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigator Lexington | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Identity Theft Diners at Puerta Grande Were Hit with Bank Fraud

Private Investigator Boone County Man Charged

A Boone County man was arrested Friday and charged with sexually molesting a minor.

At approximately 2:35 p.m., Boone County Sheriff’s detectives arrested Brandon Davis, 23, of Walton for the sexual molestation of a 15-year-old female minor on at least two occasions between February and July 2012.

http://liarcatchers.com/index.php

Davis charged with third-degree statutory rape, third-degree sodomy, and fourth-degree assault. The assault charge stems from a few domestic violence encounters with the victim where she allegedly suffered a black eye and bite mark on her arm.

Davis is being held in the Boone County Detention Center.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigator Lexington | Tagged , | Comments Off on Private Investigator Boone County Man Charged

Fraud Investigation Georgina Payne of Glasgow

A Glasgow woman has been charged with 10 counts of obtaining a controlled substance by fraud, according to a release from the Bowling Green-Warren County Drug Task Force.

The charges were in a sealed indictment returned by the Warren County grand jury after evidence on the case was presented to the grand jury on June 27 by Sgt. Tod Young of the local drug task force.

Charged is Georgina Payne, 194 Carden Road, Glasgow. Payne posted $5,000 bond and was released Tuesday from Warren County Regional Jail. She has a July 23 hearing in Warren County Circuit Court, online jail records show.

http://liarcatchers.com/fraud_investigation.html

Young presented information to the grand jury of a former nursing assistant who worked in a private physician practice in Bowling Green, the release said. The woman had been calling prescriptions for controlled substances into pharmacies on the physician’s behalf without his knowledge or approval, the release said. The offenses occurred from November 2011 through April, the release said.

The local investigation was sparked by a probe made by the 15th Judicial Drug Task Force in Hartsville, Tenn.

The Barren-Edmonson County Drug Task Force found Payne at her Barren County home and took her to the Warren County jail, the release said.

Tommy Loving, director of the local drug task force, said investigators were able to pinpoint 10 different offenses locally and hydrocodone was one of the drugs procured.

 

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigator Lexington | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Fraud Investigation Georgina Payne of Glasgow

Missing Person Skull Found Could Belong to Missing Elderly Woman

JASPER, Ala. — Initial tests show a possible link between a skull found under a house in Jasper and the case of two elderly women who’ve been missing for years.

ABC 33/40 (http://bit.ly/LLblQM) reports that a forensic pathologist has determined the skull is consistent with a small, elderly white female.

Police have said the skull could be connected to the missing person case of 104-year-old Mary Cobb and her daughter, 83-year-old Wynona Delvecchio. They were reported missing in 2005.

http://liarcatchers.com/missing_persons_investigations.html

Delvecchio once owned the house where the skull was recently found by the person who lives there now. Police say they believe the women were living in the home around the time they were last seen.

A one-time neighbor of the women was convicted of collecting retirement checks that should have gone to Cobb.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigator Lexington | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Missing Person Skull Found Could Belong to Missing Elderly Woman