Skadden vs. NYPD in the Case of the Missing Boy

Blue-chip firm Skadden Arps is throwing its considerable resources behind the sort of case that we have to imagine is pretty rare in the halls of the AmLaw 200.

It involves a missing 8-year-old boy who vanished from a New York City foster home in early 2010.

Skadden was appointed to represent the boy’s interests after his birth mother sued the city’s Administration for Children’s Services and the boy’s foster parent for allegedly failing to protect the boy, according to this New York Daily News account.

An interesting twist in the case is that Skadden is being accused by the New York Police Department of being overly meddlesome in its efforts to find its client, the Daily News reports.

Skadden wants the firm’s private investigator to be able to look at the police file for clues about the boy’s whereabouts, but the NYPD has resisted, contending that a peek at the file could compromise the identity of informants and witnesses, according to the Daily News.

Brooklyn federal magistrate Steven Gold this week sided with police, ruling that he could not order the NYPD to open the missing-person file.

Skadden, which is handling the case on a pro bono basis, has not returned a Law Blog request for comment.

In this letter sent to Gold earlier this week, Skadden attorney Jonathan Lerner wrote that it is “extremely disappointing, to say the least, that the NYPD is unwilling to allow us access to the investigative file for the specific purpose of bringing in additional professional resources to attempt to locate our client, who the NYPD has failed to find in the more than 18 months it has been investigating his disappearance.”

Lerner added in the letter that he doubted the city would deny Skadden’s request if the missing child “were from a more privileged and influential background.”

“We believed the court reached the correct decision,” Janice Silverberg, a New York City lawyer representing the police department, said in a statement to the Law Blog.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Court Ruling, Private detective | Tagged | Comments Off on Skadden vs. NYPD in the Case of the Missing Boy

The doors of her church are now open

Prophetess Deborah Ford is ready for any challenges that come her way.She has been a police officer, security guard, private investigator and school campus advisor. And Ford has faith that she will succeed in a field dominated by men that few women attempt to conquer.
She is known by many as the Prophetess Ford through her Gospel Hallelujah World Wide Radio Ministries, co-hosted with her husband, Deacon Harold Ford, since March 2007.
The Fords will be celebrating the fourth anniversary of their radio ministry with a “Red & White Holy Ghost Concert” on Saturday, Aug. 13 beginning at 6 p.m. at the Peninsula Club, 415 South Peninsula Drive in Daytona Beach.
The event, which is free to the public, will feature performances by Sir Princeton, Debra Forrest, and the Men of Excellence. Also featured will be special guests from Orlando and Daytona Beach area.
‘Passion is total ministry’
Ford accomplished her dream this week by opening the doors of her own church, which had its first meeting this past Sunday at the Comfort Inn in Daytona Beach, off of US 92, on 90 Professional Blvd.
“My passion is total ministry. I’m a Christian girl all my life. I attended Catholic school as a little girl six days a week, and on Sundays, I went to a Methodist church,” said Ford, who married her first husband, a minister, at age 19.
Ford has no regrets because her relationship with ex-husband produced three children.
Her journey allowed her to meet her current husband, Harold, while she was living in Tampa.
Ford said she was first ordained as a pastor in 1998 under Church of God in Christ denomination.
Response about women preachers
Ford said she has come across many who don’t think women should be preachers.
When they cross her path, Ford is quick to open her Bible.
“God does not have a gender. Neither male nor female in the kingdom of God. He looks at all of us as being his children,” she stated. “In the Bible, it is said He allowed a donkey to speak. Why not a woman,” she asked.
“An angel told a woman that went to the tomb to see Jesus that he was not here. “Go out and tell he is risen,” Ford added, nothing that the woman was another example of God granting women the license to preach the word.
“We’re in an extraordinary church. We worship an extraordinary God. God is all powerful and knowledgeable. He can do whatever he wants to do. Let him be God.
“We serve a God that should operate as extraordinary. Allow him to take charge and take control,” continued Ford.
She urges people to “go beyond the scriptures, what is written before and after. Who it (chapter and verse) was written for. Dissect and explore the word of God and don’t fit it to our needs. Find out the true meaning.’’
In addition to her radio ministry, Ford works as a campus advisor at Riverview Alternative Center in Daytona Beach.
The radio show can be heard locally on WPUL-AM 1590 every Sunday morning.
“We take great pride in being used by God to help the lost and to seek out those yet still in dark places, helping those needing to find salvation in Jesus Christ,” Ford concluded.
For more information, go to Deborahefordministries.com or call 386-216-6718.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private detective | Tagged | Comments Off on The doors of her church are now open

Milo selectmen reinstate police sergeant

Milo police Sgt. Damien Pickel (center) listens as his attorney N. Laurence Willey (left) speaks on Pickel’s behalf during a July, 26, 2011 press conference to discuss the dismissal of charges of domestic assault against Pickel. Listening at right is former Maine State Trooper Hank Dusenbery, a private investigator on the case. Milo Town Manager Jeff Gahagan confirmed Thursday, Aug. 4, that Pickel was reinstated at a selectmen’s meeting on Tuesday night. MILO, Maine — Milo police Sgt. Damien Pickel is back on the force after being cleared of a domestic violence assault charge.

Milo Town Manager Jeff Gahagan confirmed Thursday that Pickel, 42, was reinstated at a selectmen’s meeting on Tuesday night.

The decision was unanimous, Gahagan said.

Pickel, a former New York City police detective, was hired as a full-time officer in Milo in October 2009, and had been unemployed since he was arrested in March after his estranged wife reported that she had been assaulted by him in mid-February.

Pickel subsequently resigned from the force after being placed on unpaid administrative leave after his arrest. The Penobscot County District Attorney’s Office dismissed the domestic violence assault charge against him on July 11.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigation | Tagged | Comments Off on Milo selectmen reinstate police sergeant

West Ham United report Tottenham Hotspur to police over private investigator claims

WEST Ham believe Spurs hired a private investigator to steal bank and telephone records of senior executives during the Olympic Stadium bid process.

A statement by the club said that it had contacted police about the allegations – which they believe could result in prison sentences if proved – and was treating them with the “utmost seriousness”.

The argument relates to the bitter process to select which of the two clubs would move into the Olympic Stadium after the Games next year – which West Ham won in March.

The club believes Tottenham hired an investigator to work out West Ham’s strategy for the bid process.

In the statement, West Ham said: “This matter is being treated with the utmost seriousness by the club, especially given the methods claimed to have been used to obtain this personal information in relation to reported breaches of the Data Protection Act as a result of the unlawful acquisition of bank and telephone records belonging to senior executives at the club and the Olympic Park Legacy Committee.

“This activity, if proven, constitutes serious criminal conduct and can attract custodial sentences for perpetrators of the crime.

“In addition to the police, the matter is also now in the hands of the Information Commissioner’s Office, which investigates allegations of data protection offences.”

Tottenham attempted to seek a judicial review into the decision to hand the stadium to West Ham, but failed at a hearing at the High Court in June.

Spurs said they would not be commenting on West Ham’s allegations when contacted by the Haringey Independent.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigation | Tagged | Comments Off on West Ham United report Tottenham Hotspur to police over private investigator claims

Still no justice for slain dad

His pool was flooding. The rain wasn’t letting up. Michael Thomson opened the French doors of his bedroom and walked out onto the wet deck to sort out the problem.

Instead the 39-year-old walked into four armed men who had jumped over his neighbour’s wall.

They attacked.

The first shot hit Michael in the torso.

He fought back, disarming the robber and throwing him to the floor. He threw a second man into the pool. He jumped in after him in an attempt to drown him. The robber, armed with a screwdriver, fought back. He stabbed Michael 14 times.

The other two intruders had entered his home.

While Michael fought the robber in the pool, the first thug got to his feet and fired a shot. The father of three was shot in the back of the head.

They left him there and joined their colleagues inside the Craighall Park house. With guns against the heads of Michael’s nine- and 11-year-old children and his wife Lorna, the group worked their way through the house, looking for valuables and security cameras. All through this, his seven-year-old daughter slept.

They took some valuables, Michael’s gun and his car.

They ordered the family into a room and told them not to move. They threatened that one of them would stay behind, and if the car had a tracking device, they would be killed.

Lorna huddled with her two children until they couldn’t hear a sound.

An eternity of waiting. Then they got up to find her husband, their dad.

They searched the house. They hunted through the dark garden. They scoured the yard.

It was the seven-year-old, who had since woken up, who found her father. Dead in the pool.

This was just the beginning of the Thomson family’s nightmare.

A few days later, they discovered that the family had been hit by men who had become known as the Razor Gang.

The men had committed violent armed robberies across northern Joburg. Their modus operandi: to tie up and torture their victims, to ransack the house and, on some occasions, to rape the women in the house.

Michael’s parents Dianna and Brian Thomson have told this story countless times. And they tell it again, still looking for answers.

Sitting in a Broadacres coffee shop, Dianna has a packed lever-arch file in front of her. It documents their quest to find justice for her youngest son’s death.

Right at the top is a picture of Michael with one of his sons sitting on his shoulders. He smiles broadly. A constant reminder of her loss.

Nearly four years since her son was killed, his alleged killers are not yet in the dock. And the family has been torn apart, with three of her grandchildren now living hundreds of kilometres away. They moved to escape their trauma.

Yet they still have to remember each sequence of September 27.

Michael’s wife cannot move on, waiting for the moment she has to drop her new life in Plettenberg Bay to head back to Joburg to testify as the main witness in the case.

Despite the advice of a private investigator, a retired magistrate, police and prosecutors, and dozens of court appearances, there is still no final judgment on Michael’s alleged killers.

“My question is: Why is it taking so long? Why?” Dianna asks herself every day.

To her and her family, it’s indicative of the incompetence that has plagued the case since the start.

That September of Michael’s death, they formed a trust so that his death would not be in vain.

“We were determined that some good would come from this. We were also horrified that when the police came to the scene, there was such a lack of forensic expertise,” she says.

Among their horrors were how police insisted on getting the fire department to lift Michael’s body out of the pool. Fingerprints being taken only four days later, unused cartridges being found at the house, police officers stepping all over the crime scene. The need for proper forensics was apparent.

The family teamed up with The DNA Project, which works with Parliament to get legislation around the use of DNA to strengthen court cases. It’s the only good thing that has come out of her son’s death, says Dianna.

Progress in the investigation gave the family some relief.

Five months after Michael’s death, when police were called to quell a fight at a home in Alexandra, the parents saw the first breakthrough in their son’s murder case.

One of the men was found in possession of Michael’s gun, and led police to a house where they found several more guns.

The man had been out on bail for robbery at the time of Michael’s death.

“We were very relieved when the arrest happened. We thought, it’s just a couple of weeks before they will be in court and we will get on with it. What a joke.”

By the end of that February, police had assembled 22 cases against the Razor Gang. Prosecutors planned to combine the cases into one big docket.

“I objected to that, saying surely that was crazy.”

But Dianna’s fears were ignored.

There were legal aid postponements, one after the next. Months later, prosecutors broke the cases up again, causing more delays.

The family had not attended any court cases. They have wanted to avoid the men until the end.

“We had a retired magistrate to help us find out what’s happening with the case. He expedited the case and he got it on the roll. We thought we had someone on our side. But just as soon as he arrived, he disappeared and we never heard a word from him since.”

And then the men escaped from prison. “We were angry. But what could we do?”

When police caught the men, there was another glimmer of hope.

About a year ago they heard another Razor Gang victim, Bronwyn Patterson, talking on radio about her problems with the delays in the case.

“We thought we could pool our resources. But that didn’t work.”

Then they were told that Michael’s case was going to the High Court. Another moment of hope flashed for the family.

“But when the case was brought to the High Court, the advocate sent it back to police, saying he didn’t think the evidence was sufficiently prepared,” she says.

Six months ago, two policemen visited the family in Plettenberg Bay to go over their statements.

“That’s when we thought we were getting somewhere.”

But still no news. “We have no court date. We still know nothing.

“We are frustrated, more than anything. It’s also very frustrating for the police, who did a fine job. I’m voicing my disapproval until I’m told there’s no hope,” Dianna says.

“The pain never goes away, I can tell you that. Never. Things have never been the same. I will never forgive them for taking Michael’s life. I will try to make good come of it.” – The Star

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigation | Tagged | Comments Off on Still no justice for slain dad

Missing boy Patrick Alford: Judge won’t approve law firm’s bid to work with cops on closed case

A federal judge has nixed a powerhouse law firm’s bid to work with city cops hunting for missing 8-year-old Patrick Alford, who vanished from a city-monitored foster home.

Lawyers from Skadden, Arps were seeking access to the police investigative file for review by their respected private eye Joseph Spinelli, a former FBI agent and state inspector general.

The firm was appointed to represent Alford’s interests after his troubled mother sued the city Administration for Children’s Sevices and the Brooklyn foster parent for failing to protect the boy. The NYPD adamantly opposed giving Spinelli a look at the file, arguing it might compromise the identity of informants and witnesses.

“Our only interest in requesting the investigative file is to seek the safe return of our client,” Skadden lawyer Jonathan Lerner said in court papers.

“It is hard to believe the city would stubbornly deny this missing child the advantage of having a highly professional private investigation firm join the effort to locate him if he were from a more priviliged and influential background,” Lerner added.

Brooklyn Magistrate Steven Gold said earlier this week that he would be over-stepping his authority if he ordered the NYPD to open the missing person file.

“I’m not going to substitute my judgment for the police commissioner and the detectives who work under him to determine how to go forward,” Gold said.

Alford disappeared after his foster mother sent him to take out the trash in her Starrett City building on Jan. 22, 2010.

Cops initially focused on Alford’s mother, Jennifer Rodriguez, of Staten Island, but she has passed two lie detector tests, according to her lawyer. Rodriguez had called ACS for help while she sought drug abuse counseling.

Cops have knocked on 15,000 apartment doors, followed up on tips in New York City and out of state, interviewed dozens of bus drivers, reviewed phone records and surveillance tapes and searched on land, sea and by air.

“We are concerned that the intrusion of a private investigator could be a detriment to the well being of a child who may have been kidnapped and whose life may be in danger,” city lawyer Suzanne Halbardier said in court papers.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Court Ruling, Private Investigation | Tagged | Comments Off on Missing boy Patrick Alford: Judge won’t approve law firm’s bid to work with cops on closed case

Court rejects girl’s claims; Dunsmuir schools chief was accused

Some seven years after a student claimed a Dunsmuir High School principal harassed her and unfairly disciplined her, a federal court jury has rejected her claims.

After a five-day trial, a jury of eight women voted unanimously Tuesday to reject Dayna Padula’s claim in a lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in Sacramento.

The jury deliberated 90 minutes before reaching a decision, said Redding attorney John Kelley, who represented the Dunsmuir Joint Union High School District, former superintendent and principal Bob Morris and other district officials.

Kelley said he thought the jury reached its decision because Padula’s story changed over the years, her testimony was contradictory, and she had no corroborating witnesses.

“Her credibility was basically zero,” Kelley said Wednesday.

Kelley said he called 10 witnesses to testify in the trial, and the Padulas’ attorney called 12 witnesses.

In 2005, Padula’s family filed a lawsuit in federal court claiming that Morris singled her out and unfairly disciplined her. They also claimed that in 2003, when Padula was a freshman, he slapped her on the behind as she was walking out of Morris’ office.

The Padulas’ attorney, Anthony T. Caso, did not return phone messages left at his office Wednesday.

The allegations against Morris surfaced in 2004 when parents and students wrote letters and spoke out at district board meetings complaining about Morris’ alleged behavior, which they said included inappropriate contact, favoritism and intimidation.

Morris resigned in 2004, the same year the district hired a private investigator to look into the complaints against him.

That investigation found nearly all of the allegations against Morris could not be proved.

Padula’s mother, Pamela, said in 2007 that she thought the report was a whitewash.

Former board member Steve Rogers said Wednesday he was unhappy it took so many years for the matter to be resolved.

“I think seven years is a long time to deal with it,” Rogers said.

He blamed the controversy surrounding the allegations on the Record Searchlight. The paper “fanned the flames” by writing about the claims made by parents and students, he said.

All the while, district officials could not publicly answer the allegations, he said.

“It takes years and years for things to come out right,” Rogers said.

The newspaper successfully sued the district after it refused to turn over the 2004 investigative report. In 2007 a state appeals court ruled that the district had to make the report public. The district also had to pay the paper’s court costs, about $64,000.

Morris has retired and is living in Trinity County, Kelley said.

In the harassment case, Kelley said there were originally 21 plaintiffs who sued 11 defendants. Three of the plaintiffs dropped out, and 17 others were dismissed by the court in 2008, leaving only the Padulas to go forward for trial.

Five of the original 11 defendants were dropped from the case. The remaining defendants included Morris, current Dunsmuir High Vice Principal and teacher Raymond Kellar; former school counselor Paula Schmitt; board member William Townsend and former board member Rogers.

Kelley said the defendants are entitled to recover some of their court costs from the plaintiffs. He said the costs could be as much as $20,000

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Court Ruling, Private Investigation | Tagged | 1 Comment

Body that sat in burned garage for 2 days is a female, police say

A body that sat for two days in a Pasadena garage that had partially burned in a fire before being discovered was identified Wednesday as a female, police said.

Firefighters knocked down the blaze that had burned parts of the main home in eight minutes early Sunday and left after residents in the house said no one lived in the garage, the Pasadena Police Department said in a statement.

Several hours later, police said, fire crews returned to douse smoldering hot spots on the roof of the garage in the 100 block of South San Marino Avenue.

A private arson investigator working for the homeowner’s insurance company discovered the body Tuesday while probing the scene.

The name of the female had not been determined. Investigators also have not determined what caused the fire.

Anyone with information is asked to call police at (626) 744-4241.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigation | Tagged | Comments Off on Body that sat in burned garage for 2 days is a female, police say

Happy birthday, Mr. Obama . . . oh, wait FRAUD?

There are few who could have successfully avoided the brouhaha that has developed over Barack Obama’s birthday. There were 84.6 million responses to a Google search for those words.

But talk radio icon Rush Limbaugh is suggesting that there’s still some uncertainty.

“Tomorrow is Obama’s birthday,” he said today. “Not that we’ve seen any proof of that.”

Get the New York Times best-seller “Where’s the Birth Certificate? The Case that Barack Obama Is Not Eligible to be President,” by Jerome Corsi.

He continued, “But tomorrow is Obama’s birthday and they’re trying to rally Obama’s base by sending out fundraising letters. The issue touches on Obama’s eligibility to be president under the Constitution’s requirement that a president be a “natural-born citizen.” Numerous experts in computers, documents and imaging have stated emphatically that the “Certificate of Live Birth” image released April 27 by Obama as “proof positive” of Obama’s eligibility appears to be a forgery – which probably was created on a computer and then printed out – not an original document that was scanned and then reproduced.

California attorney Orly Taitz is scheduled to serve a subpoena on state officials in Hawaii on Monday, which is supposed to allow her to see the original documentation the state has regarding Obama’s birth
Computer scanning expert Doug Vogt and typesetting expert Paul Irey have said they will accompany Taitz when she presents to the Hawaii Department of Health the subpoena.

Vogt and Irey both told WND they are making travel plans to join Taitz in Honolulu when she goes to the state agency at 10 a.m. on Monday, Aug. 8.

“We will plan to hold a press conference late in the day of Aug. 8,” Vogt said, “and if the document we see varies from the birth certificate documents the White House released, we plan to file criminal charges in Hawaii immediately.”

The subpoena comes in a case Taitz has developed in Washington, D.C., seeking the original application for Obama’s Social Security number, a document that could provide significant information about the president’s early life that relates to his eligibility.

WND previously has reported on the issue that Obama holds a Connecticut-based Social Security number despite allegedly being born in Hawaii, starting his work career in the Aloha State and never having lived in Connecticut.

What the White House released
The first three digits of a Social Security number indicate the state of the applicant’s mailing address. Obama’s number begins with 042, which falls within Connecticut’s range of 040 through 049.

The national news media have been virtually silent on this potentially criminal fact.

Indeed, when Fox News finally attempted to explain it, the news network broadcast false information and then scrubbed the report from its website.

When WND asked the White House about the issue, then–Press Secretary Robert Gibbs dodged the question.

Taitz’ case, against Social Security Commissioner Michael Astrue, explains that because of the numerous questions surrounding Obama’s eligibility, his birth certificate and his other records, a Freedom of Information Act request was submitted.

The demand to Hawaii requires the “original 1961 typewritten birth certificate #10641 for Barack Obama … issued 08.08.1961, signed by Dr. David Sinclair, Stanley Ann Dunham Obama and registrar Lee, stored in the Health Department of the State of HI from 08081961 until now.”

As WND has reported, there long have been concerns about the Social Security number.

“There is obviously a case of fraud going on here,” says Ohio licensed private investigator Susan Daniels. “In 15 years of having a private investigator’s license in Ohio, I’ve never seen the Social Security Administration make a mistake of issuing a Connecticut Social Security number to a person who lived in Hawaii. There is no family connection that would appear to explain the anomaly.”

Does the Social Security Administration ever re-issue Social Security numbers?

“Never,” Daniels told Corsi. “It’s against the law for a person to have a re-issued or second Social Security Number issued.”

Daniels said she is “staking my reputation on a conclusion that Obama’s use of this Social Security Number is fraudulent.”

“A person who wants to hide their true identity often picks up the Social Security Number of a deceased person, thinking that nobody would ever look into it,” Daniels added. “I think it was sometime in the 1980s that Obama decided to hide who he really is.”

There is no indication in the limited background documentation released by the Obama 2008 presidential campaign or by the White House to establish that Obama ever lived in Connecticut.

Nor is there any suggestion in Obama’s autobiography, “Dreams from My Father,” that he ever had a Connecticut address.

Also, nothing can be found in the public record that indicates Obama visited Connecticut during his high-school years.

An affidavit filed by Colorado private investigator John N. Sampson specifies that as a result of his formal training as an immigration officer and his 27-year career in professional law enforcement, “it is my knowledge and belief that Social Security Numbers can only be applied for in the state in which the applicant habitually resides and has their official residence.”

Daniels told WND she believes Obama had a different Social Security Number when he worked as a teenager in Hawaii prior to 1977.

“I doubt this is President Obama’s originally issued Social Security number,” she told WND. “Obama has a work history in Hawaii before he left the islands to attend college at Occidental College in California, so he must have originally been issued a Social Security number in Hawaii.”

The published record available about Obama indicates his first job as a teenager in Hawaii was at a Baskin-Robbins in the Makiki neighborhood on Oahu. USA Today reported the ice-cream shop still was in operation one year after Obama’s inauguration.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Fraud | Tagged | 2 Comments

Spierer search could enter new phase

BLOOMINGTON – The search for a missing Indiana University student may soon focus on a Vigo County landfill. That type of search can be time-consuming, tedious and tough.

Wednesday marks two months since cameras captured Lauren Spierer leaving her Bloomington apartment to party with friends. She disappeared later than night and eight weeks later, her family still has no answers.

Now, frustration remains and the focus of the investigation may be turning toward a landfill south of Terre Haute.

Documents show Bloomington Police asked for a search warrant for the Sycamore Ridge landfill on June 16th. Officials at the landfill say they’re working with the FBI regarding a search.

If that happens, it will be challenging: looking for evidence in layer upon layer of dirt and trash. Each pile is dated by delivery, but it’s also been crushed and compacted.

Private investigator Tim Wilcox witnessed a recent landfill search, and offered his perspective on what it takes to complete.

“People have to be very meticulous in unearthing anything that looks suspicious,” Wilcox said. “They’ll have to divide it up in grids and so they’ll concentrate their effort on the areas where the most logical dumping would have taken place.”

Wilcox was hired by the family of Andrew Compton, a Carmel High School graduate, who was murdered after meeting a stranger online.

The suspect, Gregory O’Bryan, confessed to the crime and claimed he put Compton’s body in a dumpster near Louisville. What followed was a painstaking search through a southern Indiana landfill in November of 2010.

“We’re digging it up, sorting through it, putting it in the truck and then looking at it in another location, so it’s a very monotonous task of going through it,” said Louisville Metro Police Lt. Barry Wilkerson.

“Unfortunately the landfill search was uneventful and they couldn’t find anything of any substance there,” Wilcox said.

Last May, another search came up empty. IMPD dug through 60 tons of trash for ten hours in Clinton County, looking for a missing infant’s body. They found nothing.

Criminology experts tell Eyewitness News only a handful of cases that involve searching landfills actually turn up evidence. The ones that do, usually began with a very solid lead. For some families, there’s still no closure.

“The Compton family is extremely agonizing over this,” Wilcox said. The hope is that a potential search in Vigo County would be successful and help find some clue to bring Lauren Spierer home.

On the two-month mark since her disappearance, the “News on Lauren S” twitter account says friends and family are writing messages to Lauren. The letters are being posted on the family’s blog.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
Posted in Private Investigation | Tagged | Comments Off on Spierer search could enter new phase